Operation
Coronet
  Operation
Olympic
  Operation
Sealion
   
 
  Operation Sealion

Problems

Famous Quotes

Books
   Hitler Options
   Invasion
   Invasion!
   Invasion, 1940
   Operation Sea Lion
   SS-GB

DVDs
   It Happened Here


 
   
Operation Sealion   >   Books   >   Invasion

Invasion: The Alternate History of the German Invasion of England, July 1940


In this book, Kenneth Macksey writes the story, as if a historical account, of the German invasion of Britain. Rather than going for the usual Sealion plan, when the Germans invade in the Autumn, Macksey sets the invasion in July 1940, immediately after the fall of France. This scenario probably makes the the invasion somewhat more likely of success in purely military terms than an Autumn invasion - as British strength was probably at its lowest point in July - but it also involves several (in my opinion) probably unrealistic assumptions:
  1. That the Germans would have anticipated the rapid, and relatively easy, defeat of France.

  2. That the Germans would have anticipated that Britain would not surrender or negotiate after the fall of France, and therefore invasion would be necessary.

  3. That the Germans would have realized during the French campaign that victory was imminent, and that some forces could then be safely withdrawn from the frontline, in order to prepare for the invasion of Britain.

  4. That the Germans would have been able to improvise an invasion force at very short notice.
In reality, I'm not sure that any of these assumptions are true. The Germans did not anticipate defeating France as easily as they did, did not anticipate Britain fighting on after the fall of France, remained cautious and conservative during the French campaign (because they overestimated the likelihood of successful counterattacks), and when they did start preparing to invade Britain, took rather a long time over their preparations.

My other criticisms with the book's portrayal of the invasion are the usual problems with Sealion scenarios: the Royal Navy, and logistics - both of which, in reality, the Germans would have, to put it mildly, struggled with. However, in this book, the naval battles go surprisingly well for the Germans, and logistical problems somehow don't impede the invasion too much either.

I understand Kenneth Macksey is a former armor officer, so he concentrates on the land battles, and he does so well and convincingly. There is a tremendous amount of military-technical detail in the text, and you may find yourself having to read some passages more than once in order to fully understand them. Fortunately, the book does contain many maps which are help greatly in understanding.

As to which side wins, I won't say, but you can probably guess. I don't want to blow the ending, but I will say this it doesn't involve the Germans fighting street by street through the rubble of London, nor gradually running out of food and ammo' while surrounded by Tommies.

Over all this is good excellent book, and I'd recommend it without reservation. Yes, there are in my opinion some unrealistic assumptions, but who is to say that my opinion is right? I think the author has done a superb job of constructing a Sealion scenario in which Germans have the best possible chance of success, and while there are things that I think might be somewhat unlikely, I don't think there is anything that is ridiculously implausible.

You will enjoy reading this book - buy it!

Related Links:

Invasion: The Alternate History of the German Invasion of England, July 1940

By Kenneth Macksey

Greenhill Books
Paperback (224 pages)

Invasion: The Alternate History of the German Invasion of England, July 1940
List Price: $22.95
Lowest New Price: $12.34
Lowest Used Price: $8.98
Usually ships in 24 hours
(As of 12:45 Pacific 15 May 2008 More Info)


Click Here
Product Description:
In June 1940, as German troops massed across the Channel, poised for the invasion of Britain, Hitler seemed ready for his greatest gamble. In this compelling alternate history the Germans actually launch the invasion. Landing between Dover and Hythe, German troops push inland, supported by the Luftwaffe and the panzers, and strike toward London. A classic and harrowing insight into how Britain's war might have gone.

Invasion - The Alternate History of the German Invasion of England, July 1940

By Kenneth Macksey

Wrens Park Publishing
Hardcover
Lowest Used Price: $4.99
(As of 12:45 Pacific 15 May 2008 More Info)


Click Here

Invasion : The Alternate History of the German Invasion of England, July 1940

By Kenneth Macksey

Greenhill Books
Paperback
 

Aces High 468 Banner




 
   
World War II
Operation Barbarossa
1941 German Invasion of Russia
Operation Citadel
1943 The Battle of Kursk
Operation Dragoon
1944 Invasion of southern France
Operation Varsity
1945 Crossing the Rhine

Invasions That Never Were
Operation Sealion
1940 German invasion of England
Operation Olympic
1945 US invasion of southern Japan
Operation Coronet
1946 US invasion of northern Japan

Special Forces
Operation Entebbe
1976 Entebbe Airport Rescue
Operation Nimrod
1980 Iranian Embassy Siege

British Cold War Operations
Operation Musketeer
1956 Suez Crisis
Operation Corporate
1982 Falklands War
Operation Black Buck
1982 Vulcan raids on Port Stanley
Operation Granby
1990-91 Persian Gulf

British Post Cold War
Operation Herrick
2002- Afghanistan


 
 
 
 
 
   

 
       
Copyright (C) 2007-2008, Answers 2000 Limited

Privacy   Terms of Use

In Association With Amazon.com
In Assocation With AllPosters.com

All trademarks are property of their respective owners.
All third party content and adverts are copyright of their respective owners.